Art Guilt, Part II: Crimes Against My Youth

by JHF on August 14, 2009 · 6 comments

in Personal

The revelations have been coming at me like a freaking avalanche for about a week. I hardly know where to start, but last night’s surf band gig is probably as good a place as any.

The venue was a concert at the Taos Community Auditorium to benefit an after-school music program at the high school. Entitled “Guitar Spectacular,” the event featured half a dozen local guitar gods and the inimitable Los Changos del Mar, with yours truly on rhythm guitar. I may have more to say about the show itself later. All you really need to know now is that by some miracle, I not only played halfway decently but had a good time, and the band rocked. When the concert was over, one of the aforementioned guitar gods came up to us, face beaming, to declare, “Man, you guys were a MESS! I thought that was just great!” Our almost-19-year-old drummer found himself compared to Ginger Baker, drummer for Cream:

“Who’s Ginger Baker?” he said.

You may be sure we gave him hell, but you have to give the man credit for not being afraid to ask. And that, I suppose, is one of the clues. The valedictorian of Peñasco High School and scholarship winner is leaving for the University of California at Santa Cruz in a few days. He already plays drums, guitar, bass, bouzouki, and a bunch of things I don’t even know about. At the risk of damaging his cool, I’ll even say that in our relatively short acquaintance so far, I haven’t detected any vile anti-social habits, behavioral or otherwise. In short, if the guy was selling stock in himself, I’d say put me down for a thousand shares.

Obviously, I’m a fan, but what I realize now is that he’s not the only one. My attention has been zeroing in on other up-and-coming young guys over the last few years in what may be an age thing: if I’d been a father (in my 40s!), these kids could be my boys, perhaps, or maybe it’s an expression of male pride. “Hey, look at what we can do,” something like that. But after I got home last night, I took a look at the U.C. Santa Cruz website, thinking about the drummer. Lord, was I envious. I wished I could shoot myself so I could reincarnate sooner and do it all over again, only the right way, like he was getting to do. But why “right”? Hadn’t I had a full life? Out of the blue, it came crashing home: I could have been just like him, if anyone had ever helped me…

It’ll take the book I have to write to do justice to the subject, but I want to tell you, this was staggering.

I’ve known intellectually for a long time what my parents did or didn’t do, but until that moment, I’d never felt the full weight of what it meant. They never encouraged me, except to push me in directions they thought I should go, and even then it was more like training a dog. I must have scared them to death: if the kid was Michelangelo, they’d have to smother him, because he’d never have a JOB… My gifts, my talents, were never nurtured. Most of what I accomplished happened out out of thin air or on my own volition, to the extent that I could get away with it, followed by indifference or disapproval. No one ever told me, “You can do it!”

Here’s a good one for you:

When I was in 5th or 6th grade, my father announced that he’d be handing out 25 cents (a whole quarter!) for each “A” on our report cards. That was wonderful news, because A’s were all I ever got, andI immediately started dreaming of the model airplane or Jerry Lee Lewis 45 I’d be able to buy. When report cards came out, my sister, brother, and I stood in line to meet my father when he came home. Sure enough, he had a pocket full of quarters, and I can still see my younger siblings running down the hall with their winnings in hand. But when it came my turn to be rewarded, he said, “Sorry, not for you.”

“B-but why not?” I stammered, heartbroken and confused.

“Because we expect you to get A’s,” he said. In other words, my sister and brother had to work to earn their high marks, but for me, it just came naturally and didn’t count. “It wouldn’t be fair to them,” my mother added. Brilliant. Just fucking brilliant: not only did I get kicked in the teeth, they made me feel guilty for being smart.

So I thought about the drummer and my own life, and how sure, I went to college and earned a couple of degrees in subjects I didn’t give a damn about. One way or the other, I had a crazy life and did a lot of things I wanted to, but essentially, I was crippled. Always doubting and beating up on myself. I could never make anything work for me for long. And I certainly didn’t start life away from home by winning a scholarship to a goddamn gorgeous campus on the California coast to study anything that I was passionate about!

When you’ve just turned 64 and this hits you like a locomotive in the guts, you might end up crying in the bathroom at 2:00 a.m. like I did. It isn’t pretty, but it happens. I cried some this morning and I’ll cry again until it’s all washed out of me. Those fucking bastards. It’s like waking up and realizing you’ve been gelded and didn’t know it. Well, great. The scales have fallen from mine eyes, and now I can be anything I want: I’M JUST FUCKING OLD, that’s all!!!

Angrier, stronger, and holier than ever, too.

Related posts:

  1. Art Guilt, Part I
  2. Art Guilt V: True Grit
  3. Art Guilt III: Magic Bullet in the Neck
  4. Yellow Varnish
  5. Christmas Music, Part III

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

1 KarenK August 14, 2009 at 10:01 am

John, I’m so sorry for the pain afforded by your journey of self-discovery. I’m sorry you feel it’s too late to be helped. But maybe you can take all of your hard-earned wisdom and scars and become the helper. Provide the mentoring support for some unfortunate younger person that your father never gave to you. You’ve seen firsthand how parents can cripple their unfortunate progeny — either through ignorance or by retaliating against their own unnamed demons. Maybe you could approach and conquer your demons from the other side of the equation. (Man, this sounds preachy. I don’t mean it that way.) Yes, it may be too late to be the nurtured child. But decidedly not too late to turn the tables and nurture one. Make up for the sins of your father. That will show him! You have to be OLD to do that!

Reply

2 JHF August 14, 2009 at 10:23 am

No, no, no, not too late! :-) No worries. All love comes from the same source, decent parents just make it easier to plug into. Survivors like me have to find the outlet, over and over again. Just part of the ride. This is actually a GREAT background for any kind of artist, of course. There’s an interesting comment thread on this over at FaceBook, BTW, where I can’t seem to train people to come here and comment. Aarghh.

You’re also right about the backside of “old.” Jungian analysts don’t generally even like to mess with people who aren’t at least in their 50s. The ruts have to be deep enough to really feel them!

(And Nakul, if you’re reading this, don’t worry a bit. I’m fine. It’s just that getting to know you better has helped me to understand myself a little more. Just get out there and have a freaking BLAST!)

Reply

3 Steve Ingham August 14, 2009 at 3:05 pm

I just want to say this about your last sentence…..
“RIGHT FUCKING ON” John!!

Steve

Reply

4 cjs August 18, 2009 at 2:02 pm

Yes. This is a heart-breaker: to think (at whatever age) “Holy shit, it’s too late for me to do X or Y or Z!” For me personally, it’s every time I hear a Hindustani musician, and think to myself, “the only way I would ever have been able to play that music would be if I had started at age 6 and kept on ’til the present. I’m never going to play that music in this life.”

I empathize and sympathize with your personal history, too: denial of talent, squelching of opportunity, parental dysfunction, the whole sorry mess, is in my background too.

Something that has helped me is an insight from (very many years!) of therapy, in groups with people whose personal histories were far more damaging than ever happened to me. I would be listening to some horrific story of abuse, and awestruck that the victim was sitting there in front of us, grappling with that history, and that I was hearing them say, essentially,

“I can’t undo what was done to me. But I can make sure it fucking stops with me.”

I learned from those people, to begin to apply the same lesson to my own life history. Whatever was done to us, whatever resentments and regrets we are doomed to carry to the grave, we can begin to say “the shit stops with me.” We can make the choice to heal, and to put good energy out into the world.

And if the youngsters, the ones who come after us, the ones who (because of our own resolution not to replicate the shit) reach the kind of artistic completion that we can’t, because of age or damage, then at least we are putting good energy out into the world.

And we can’t ever know upon what distant shores the ripples of that good energy will be felt.

Peace, brother.

Reply

5 JHF August 18, 2009 at 2:39 pm

Hi Chris, great to see you here!

Yes, total agreement on all points. What Jungian analysis has taught me, additionally, is that for me at least, the path to wholeness leads through real-time experience of buried pain. Taking the full impact now, as a grownup, washes so much away. In the case of the above post, just getting to know Nakul a little better drove home the emotional massiveness of the abuse I suffered. I’ve always known, intellectually, but it didn’t really hurt. I’d walled it off so it wouldn’t, and in so doing also encapsulated the lies that caused the pain…

Since writing this post, I’ve been on an extended high of sorts, in a real creative whirlwind, and I think I know why: the evil inner critic is gone, or at least went into hiding. It had to, because what hit me in the bathroom put the lie to any claim to legitmacy it had: the inner critic is a FUCKING NUTBALL PSYCHO SADIST!!! I don’t have to listen any more, just like I don’t have to answer every phone call. I have wanted this to be “over” for so goddamned long, but it wouldn’t go away until I felt it. Stupid karma! No way do we ever get a refund.

This shit stops with me, not because I will it, but because the energy is transmuted. Hah!

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: